From ac82bd45d4bd9d409e97baae0dc548ceb80b6a0f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Richard Newman <rnewman@twinql.com>
Date: Wed, 19 Oct 2016 09:24:04 -0700
Subject: [PATCH] Updated Proposal: application schema coordination and
 versioning (markdown)

---
 ...tion-schema-coordination-and-versioning.md | 90 +++++++++++++++++++
 1 file changed, 90 insertions(+)

diff --git a/Proposal:-application-schema-coordination-and-versioning.md b/Proposal:-application-schema-coordination-and-versioning.md
index 66dfe5e..58ebb63 100644
--- a/Proposal:-application-schema-coordination-and-versioning.md
+++ b/Proposal:-application-schema-coordination-and-versioning.md
@@ -85,3 +85,93 @@ This is similar to the 'user version' functionality in SQLite, with important di
 - Many schema changes -- adding attributes, altering indexing choices, or weakening constraints -- can be performed automatically with no need to supply migration code.
 
 Under this proposal different applications can each ship shared schema fragments, coordinate upgrades, avoid conflicts in a large majority of cases, and safely detect real conflicts when they arise.
+
+# An example
+
+Let's start with a very simple core schema: pages have URLs and titles.
+
+```
+{:schema/name "org.mozilla.core.page"
+ :schema/version 1
+ :schema/attributes [
+   {:db/id (d/id-literal :db.part/user)
+    :db/ident              :page/url
+    :db/valueType          :db.type/string          ; Because not all URLs are java.net.URIs. For JS we may want to use /uri.
+    :db/fulltext           true
+    :db/cardinality        :db.cardinality/one
+    :db/unique             :db.unique/identity
+    :db/doc                "A page's URL."
+    :db.install/_attribute :db.part/db}
+   {:db/id (d/id-literal :db.part/user)
+    :db/ident              :page/title
+    :db/valueType          :db.type/string
+    :db/fulltext           true
+    :db/cardinality        :db.cardinality/one      ; We supersede as we see new titles.
+    :db/doc                "A page's title."
+    :db.install/_attribute :db.part/db}]}
+```
+
+Adding an attribute is easy: the version number doesn't need to change.
+
+```
+{:schema/name "org.mozilla.core.page"
+ :schema/version 1
+ :schema/attributes [
+   …   ;; Previous attributes elided for clarity.
+   {:db/id (d/id-literal :db.part/user)
+    :db/ident              :page/visit
+    :db/valueType          :db.type/ref
+    :db/cardinality        :db.cardinality/one
+    :db/doc                "A visit to the page."
+    :db.install/_attribute :db.part/db}]}
+```
+
+But we erroneously marked `:page/visit` as cardinality-one: you can only ever visit a page once!
+
+That's an easy automated fix: it's not possible for existing cardinality-one data to violate a cardinality-many restriction. So we fix it and bump the schema version. Datomish will weaken the constraint automatically.
+
+```
+{:schema/name "org.mozilla.core.page"
+ :schema/version 2
+ :schema/attributes [
+   …
+   {:db/id (d/id-literal :db.part/user)
+    :db/ident              :page/visit
+    :db/valueType          :db.type/ref
+    :db/cardinality        :db.cardinality/many          ; Weaken this.
+    :db/doc                "A visit to the page."
+    :db.install/_attribute :db.part/db}]}
+```
+
+Then we recognize that we made another mistake. Visits should be unique: two pages can't share a single visit. We're confident in our application code, though, so we can again just change the schema without writing any code.
+
+```
+{:schema/name "org.mozilla.core.page"
+ :schema/version 3
+ :schema/attributes [
+   …
+   {:db/id (d/id-literal :db.part/user)
+    :db/ident              :page/visit
+    :db/valueType          :db.type/ref
+    :db/unique             :db.unique/value              ; Add this.
+    :db/cardinality        :db.cardinality/many
+    :db/doc                "A visit to the page."
+    :db.install/_attribute :db.part/db}]}
+```
+
+If we wanted to be thorough, we would supply a query like this to run when transitioning to schema version 3:
+
+```
+;; This query is incorrect, but you get the idea.
+[:find [?e ?a ?v ?t]
+ :in $
+ :where
+ [?ex :page/visit ?v ?tx]
+ [?e :page/visit ?v ?t]
+ [(!= ?ex ?e)]
+ [(ground :page/visit) ?a]]
+```
+
+This simply finds surplus datoms so they can be retracted prior to applying the schema change.
+
+In the general case, code needs to run against the open datom store in order to perform the schema change — for example, one might want to preserve old data using new vocabulary before altering the old schema — so a simple approach like the above isn't always enough.
\ No newline at end of file