testregex/docs/re-categorize.html

210 lines
12 KiB
HTML
Raw Permalink Normal View History

<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Frameset//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-html40/frameset.dtd">
<HTML>
<HEAD>
<META name="generator" content="mm2html (AT&T Labs Research) 2005-10-15">
<META name="keywords" content="regex implementation categorization">
<TITLE> ../re/re-categorize.mm mm document </TITLE>
<META name="author" content="gsf">
</HEAD>
<BODY bgcolor=white link=slateblue vlink=teal >
<TABLE border=0 align=center width=96%>
<TBODY><TR><TD valign=top align=left>
<!--INDEX--><!--/INDEX-->
<P>
<HR>
<CENTER>
<H3><CENTER><FONT color=red><FONT face=courier>regex implementation categorization</FONT></FONT></CENTER></H3>
<BR>Glenn Fowler <SMALL>&lt;<A href=mailto:gsf@research.att.com>gsf@research.att.com</A>&gt;</SMALL>
<P><I>AT&amp;T Labs Research - Florham Park NJ</I>
</CENTER>
<P><HR><P>
The
<STRONG>regex</STRONG>
tests in
<A href="http://web.archive.org/web/20080726034626id_/http://www.research.att.com/~gsf/testregex/categorize.dat">categorize.dat</A>
attempt to categorize
<STRONG>regex</STRONG>
implementations.
The tests do not address internationalization.
All implementations report the leftmost match; this is omitted from the table.
<P></P><TABLE border=0 frame=void rules=none width=100%><TBODY><TR><TD>
<TABLE align=center bgcolor=papayawhip border=0 bordercolor=white cellpadding=2 cellspacing=2 frame=void rules=none >
<TBODY>
<TR><TD align=center>LABEL&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;ASSOC&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;SUBEXPR&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;REP_LONGEST&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;BUGS</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
A&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;precedence&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;-</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
B&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-short&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
D&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;-</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
G&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;alternation-order&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
H&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;alternation-order&nbsp;&nbsp;nomatch-match&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
I&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-any&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-short&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
J&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;precedence&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;last&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;nomatch-match&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch&nbsp;&nbsp;subexpression-first</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
M&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;precedence&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;last&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;range-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch&nbsp;&nbsp;subexpression-first</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
O&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-short&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
P&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;alternation-order&nbsp;&nbsp;first-match&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
R&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;left&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;precedence&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;last&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;-</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
S&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-short&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
T&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;left&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;precedence&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;last&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;-</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
U&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;precedence&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;subexpression-first</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
darwin.ppc&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-short</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
freebsd.i386&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-short</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
hp.pa&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
ibm.risc&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;alternation-order&nbsp;&nbsp;nomatch-match&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact-nomatch</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
linux.i386&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;alternation-order&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
sgi.mips3&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-short</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
sol8.sun4&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;grouping&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;alternation-order&nbsp;&nbsp;nomatch-match&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-artifact</TD></TR>
<TR><TD align=center>
unixware.i386&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;right&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;precedence&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;first&nbsp;&nbsp;</TD><TD align=center>&nbsp;&nbsp;repeat-null&nbsp;&nbsp;subexpression-first</TD></TR>
</TBODY></TABLE></TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
<P>
The categories are:
<DL COMPACT>
<DL COMPACT>
<DT><STRONG>LABEL</STRONG><DD>
The implementation label from
<A href="http://web.archive.org/web/20080726034626id_/http://www.research.att.com/~gsf/testregex/">testregex.</A>
<DT><STRONG>ASSOC</STRONG><DD>
Subpattern (or atom) associativity: either
<STRONG>left</STRONG>
or
<STRONG>right</STRONG>.
The subexpression match rule in the rationale requires
<STRONG>right</STRONG>
for expressions where each concatenated part is a subexpression.
There is no definition for
<EM>subpattern</EM>,
but it would be inconsistent for any definition to require different
associativity than that for subexpressions.
Some claim that the BRE and ERE grammars specify
<STRONG>left</STRONG>
associativity, but this interpretation disregards
the subexpression match rule in the rationale.
The grammar can also be interpreted to support
<STRONG>right</STRONG>
associativity, and this interpretation is in accord with the rationale.
<DT><STRONG>SUBEXPR</STRONG><DD>
Subexpression semantics:
<STRONG>precedence</STRONG>
if subexpressions can override the default associativity;
<STRONG>grouping</STRONG>
if subexpressions are for repetition and
<STRONG>regmatch_t</STRONG>
grouping only.
The subexpression match rule in the rationale requires
<STRONG>precedence</STRONG>.
<DT><STRONG>REP_LONGEST</STRONG><DD>
How repeated subexpressions that match more than once are handled:
<STRONG>first</STRONG>
if the longest possible matches occur first;
<STRONG>last</STRONG>
if the longest possible matches occur last;
<STRONG>unknown</STRONG>
otherwise.
The subexpression match rule in the rationale requires
<STRONG>first</STRONG>.
<DT><STRONG>BUGS</STRONG><DD>
Miscellaneous bugs (see
<A href="http://web.archive.org/web/20080726034626id_/http://www.research.att.com/~gsf/testregex/categorize.dat">categorize.dat</A>
for specific examples):
<DL COMPACT>
<DL COMPACT>
<DT><STRONG>alternation-order</STRONG><DD>
A change in the order of subexpression alternation operands,
<EM>not involved in a tie</EM>,
changes
<STRONG>regmatch_t</STRONG>
values.
Some implementations with this bug can be coaxed into missing the
overall longest match.
<DT><STRONG>first-match</STRONG><DD>
The first of the leftmost matches, instead of the longest of the
leftmost matches, is returned.
<DT><STRONG>nomatch-match</STRONG><DD>
A back-reference to a
<STRONG>regmatch_t</STRONG>
(-1,-1) value is treated as matching.
<DT><STRONG>range-null</STRONG><DD>
A range-repeated subexpression that matches null does not report the match
at offset (0,0).
<DT><STRONG>repeat-artifact</STRONG><DD>
A
<STRONG>regmatch_t</STRONG>
value is reported for a repeated match that is not the last match.
<DT><STRONG>repeat-artifact-nomatch</STRONG><DD>
To prevent not matching,
a
<STRONG>regmatch_t</STRONG>
value is reported for a repeated match that is not the last match.
<DT><STRONG>repeat-null</STRONG><DD>
A repeated subexpression matches the null string even though it is not
the only match and is not necessary to satisfy the exact or minimum
number of occurrences for an interval expression.
<DT><STRONG>repeat-short</STRONG><DD>
Incorrect
<STRONG>regmatch_t</STRONG>
values for a repeated subexpression.
This may be a variant of
<STRONG>repeat-artifact</STRONG>.
<DT><STRONG>subexpression-first</STRONG><DD>
A subexpression match takes precedence over a subpattern
to its left.
</DL>
</DL>
</DL>
</DL>
<P>
<HR>
<TABLE border=0 align=center width=96%>
<TR>
<TD align=left></TD>
<TD align=center></TD>
<TD align=right><A href="mailto:gsf@research.att.com?subject= ../re/re-categorize.mm mm document">Glenn Fowler</A></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD align=left></TD>
<TD align=center></TD>
<TD align=right>Information and Software Systems Research</TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD align=left></TD>
<TD align=center></TD>
<TD align=right>AT&amp;T Labs Research</TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD align=left></TD>
<TD align=center></TD>
<TD align=right>Florham Park NJ</TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD align=left></TD>
<TD align=center></TD>
<TD align=right>June 01, 2004</TD>
</TR>
</TABLE>
<P>
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
</BODY>
</HTML>